Warm afternoon light crosses a pale stone kitchen island, ivory cabinets and an oak dining table, with russet oak trees visible through closed windows.

Who's Cooking Thanksgiving in Dix Hills This Year? The Pre-Order Deadlines and Pickup Windows to Know

Thanksgiving lands on Thursday, November 26. For anyone in Dix Hills who plans to order part of the meal, the dates that count come earlier: Saturday, November 21 at 9 p.m., and Sunday, November 22 at noon. From the first week of November, those cutoffs are a little more than two weeks off.

Three kitchens close to the hamlet have posted 2026 Thanksgiving menus. Each one is set up to take a different part of the work off your hands. Pino's Italian Food Market on Old Country Road sells a whole meal with courses you choose, and it also sells turkeys by the pound. Corinne's Concepts in Catering on East Jericho Turnpike sells everything à la carte. Uncle Giuseppe's in Melville sells packages sized for big crowds, and it's the only one of the three with pickup on Thanksgiving morning. Once you know which part of the meal you want to hand off, you know which kitchen fits and which date matters to you.

The calendar first

Pino's, Dix Hills Uncle Giuseppe's, Melville Corinne's, Huntington Station
Order by Sun., Nov. 22, 12 p.m. Sat., Nov. 21, 9 p.m. Not printed; call 631-351-6030
Pickup Wed., Nov. 25, before 6 p.m. Wed., Nov. 25, 8 a.m.–7 p.m., or Thu., Nov. 26, 7 a.m.–12 p.m. Curbside; call for timing
How it's sold Feast packages or turkey by the pound Packages or à la carte half trays À la carte
Comes home Cold, with heating instructions Cold Not specified on menu
Thanksgiving Day Closed Open for morning pickup Not specified on menu

The Melville deadline is the earliest, by 15 hours. Uncle Giuseppe's closes orders Saturday night. Pino's takes them until Sunday at noon. If you're deciding between the two, the weekend before the holiday is when you'll have to choose.

Pino's: the whole meal, with an Italian first course

Newsday reported in April 2025 that the family behind the original Salpino's markets in Wantagh and Babylon had expanded north to 683 Old Country Road in Dix Hills. The store is just under 15,000 square feet, the largest of the company's three. The family says it has been feeding Long Island since 1985, so this is the Dix Hills store's second Thanksgiving under a menu with decades behind it.

The 2026 Thanksgiving Feast works like a set menu where you pick one item from each course:

  • Antipasto: a traditional antipasto platter or a mozzarella caprese platter
  • First course: penne alla vodka, cavatelli Calabrese, baked ziti, meat or cheese lasagna, stuffed shells or manicotti
  • Cornbread stuffing: crisp apple and sausage meat, or sautéed spinach, onions and pancetta
  • Main course: an all-natural, fully cooked whole young turkey, about 16 pounds cooked, carved for an extra $15, or a fresh raw turkey instead
  • Two vegetables: string bean casserole, oven-roasted Brussels sprouts, candied sweet potatoes, mashed potatoes or string bean almondine
  • Dessert: homemade pumpkin or apple pie, or a fresh-cut fruit bowl

The pasta course is what sets this menu apart. A Long Island Italian Thanksgiving usually serves something like baked ziti before the turkey, and Pino's makes that a standard course you pick from, alongside the turkey.

The pricing runs from $99.99 plus tax for a smaller prix fixe that serves 4 to 6, up to packages at $349.99 and $449.99 plus tax. The menu lists the larger two next to sizes of 10 to 12 people and up to 25. It's printed so that the price for each size is hard to read, so confirm the pairing when you call the Dix Hills store at 631-916-4437. The packages include a pint of homemade cranberry sauce.

Or just the bird

Hosts who'd rather make the sides themselves can order only the turkey from Pino's:

  • Fully cooked Bell & Evans whole young turkey, $3.99 per pound
  • Fresh, never-frozen free-range young turkey, $2.99 per pound, with cleaning and oven prep for an extra $15
  • Oven-ready whole turkey breast, $6.99 per pound
  • Oven-ready, free-range boneless turkey breast roast, $6.99 per pound

All Pino's orders go home cold and get reheated in your oven. Heating instructions are posted on the store's website, and the store is closed on Thanksgiving Day. Your pickup is Wednesday before 6 p.m., so you'll need room in the refrigerator Wednesday night for a 16-pound turkey plus trays.

Corinne's: around your own turkey

Corinne's Concepts in Catering is at 845 East Jericho Turnpike in Huntington Station. Its "Thanksgiving Menu 2026" has no set packages. Every item is priced on its own, and pickup is curbside. That makes it the best fit for a host who plans to roast the turkey at home and wants help with the rest of the meal.

Many of the sides come in three sizes. Small serves 2 to 4, medium serves 4 to 6 and large serves 8 to 10, so you can match the order to your guest count:

  • Mashed potatoes or traditional stuffing: $22, $35 or $55
  • Candied sweet potatoes or sweet potato soufflé with mini marshmallows: $22, $35 or $60
  • Sausage stuffing: $30, $38 or $60
  • Corn pudding: $22, $35 or $55
  • By the pound: string beans almondine and vegetable medley sauté at $13, Red Jacket roasted potatoes at $13, mandarin cranberry compote with walnuts at $17, creamed spinach at $20

Before dinner, there are seven gourmet dips at $10 a pound, including spinach, roasted pepper and garlic, and Kalamata olive. Baked brie en croute is $40 small or $50 large, and jumbo shrimp cocktail is $60 a dozen. After dinner, pumpkin and apple crumb pies are $25 each, and pecan and chocolate pecan pies are $35 each.

Corinne's also sells turkey: roasted turkey at $9.95 per pound by raw weight, and sliced roasted turkey breast at $19 per pound. Pino's prices its fully cooked bird at $3.99 per pound, so check whether each price is based on raw or cooked weight before you compare them. A stuffed boneless capon is $22, and gravies are $16 a quart.

The menu has no printed order deadline or pickup window, so call 631-351-6030. Corinne's lists hours of Tuesday through Saturday, 10:30 a.m. to 6 p.m., and Sunday, 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. It's closed Mondays, so call on another day.

Uncle Giuseppe's: big tables and Thursday morning pickup

Uncle Giuseppe's is at 890 Walt Whitman Road in Melville, just outside Dix Hills. Its packages are the largest of the three kitchens:

  • Serves 8 to 10: $299.99
  • Serves 14 to 16: $499.99
  • Serves up to 24: $799.99

Each package lets you choose appetizers, a soup or salad, a pasta, a turkey entrée, sides, cranberry sauce, desserts and gravy. At full capacity, the 24-person package works out to about $33 per guest. The 8-to-10 package comes to roughly $30 to $37 per guest, depending on how many people you're feeding.

Hosts who only need a few things can order à la carte half trays that serve 6 to 8. Appetizers start at $19.99, turkey entrées at $59.99, sides at $39.99, desserts at $6.99 and pies at $16.99.

The pickup schedule sets Uncle Giuseppe's apart. You can pick up Wednesday, November 25, from 8 a.m. to 7 p.m., or on Thanksgiving morning from 7 a.m. to noon. With Thursday pickup, the food doesn't have to spend the night in your refrigerator, which helps if that space is already full of drinks and desserts. The food is supplied cold, like Pino's, and orders close Saturday, November 21, at 9 p.m.

Matching the kitchen to your table

Taken together, the three menus cover different kinds of hosting:

You're hosting 4 to 6 people and don't want to cook. Pino's $99.99 prix fixe is the smallest full meal on any of the three menus.

You want a pasta course and a turkey on the same table. Pino's Feast includes both, with six pastas to choose from.

You roast the turkey yourself and just need help with the sides. Corinne's sizes its sides by headcount, so you can order a small corn pudding and a large mashed potatoes for the same table.

You make the sides and just want someone else to handle the bird. Pino's sells fully cooked and raw turkeys by the pound.

You're feeding 20 or more, or your refrigerator is full Wednesday night. Uncle Giuseppe's has a package for up to 24 and the only Thanksgiving-morning pickup.

Wednesday on Jericho Turnpike

If you're picking up on Wednesday, Ralph's Famous Italian Ices is also on Jericho Turnpike. Newsday reported in August that the Dix Hills shop had moved across the street to a new storefront at 1740 E. Jericho Turnpike. Owner Nanci Lotvin told the paper, "There's not one thing in the store that's not brand new." The menu includes 12 signature sundaes and hard ice cream flavors like Mississippi mud and vanilla graham cracker. That could be an easy dessert for the kids' table, or a way to keep the kids busy on Wednesday afternoon.

The hours in that report were summer hours: 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Monday through Thursday, and until 10:30 p.m. Friday through Sunday. Call 631-493-4444 to check the hours for Thanksgiving week before you plan a stop.

Feeding a crowd at Thanksgiving is often when people notice whether their kitchen and dining room still fit the way they host. If this year's planning has you thinking about more counter space or a bigger table, Robyn Schatz and the team are happy to talk it through with you, and they can start with a free home valuation.

Move Smarter & Live Better

Unlock the advantage of working with someone who sees the details others miss, blends strategy with intuition, and makes your goals the top priority.

Follow Me on Instagram